About After the Storm Counseling-Therapy in Columbus, Ohio
It's about people
At After the Storm Counseling, we believe therapy is about something bigger than checking a box or treating a diagnosis. It's about people — making sense of what they've been through, working through anxiety, depression, trauma, or a season of life they never expected. We know reaching out isn't easy, which is why the relationship you build with your therapist matters most.
Our team of licensed therapists brings over 100 years of combined clinical experience to anxiety therapy, depression treatment, trauma and EMDR, couples counseling, and family therapy — across our Worthington, Westerville, Grandview, and Pickerington offices, and by secure telehealth throughout Ohio.
Your therapy should fit you
There's no one-size-fits-all approach to mental health. Every person brings their own history, personality, and goals into therapy, and your treatment should reflect that — not the other way around. Our therapists draw from evidence-based approaches like CBT, EMDR, and trauma-informed care, choosing what's most helpful for you rather than applying a standard formula. You're an active participant in your care, not a recipient of someone else's plan.
Led by clinical expertise
After the Storm Counseling is led by Dr. Cindy Herzberg, Ed.D, LPCC-S, a doctorate-level Licensed Professional Clinical Counselor with Supervision and over 25 years in the field, with advanced training in trauma and somatic care. That expertise shapes our whole approach to treatment — and every therapist on our team is fully licensed (LPCC, LISW, or LPC) and supervised to the highest clinical standard.
Professional and human
Our clinicians use evidence-informed approaches and continue learning throughout their careers — but being a good therapist takes more than credentials. It takes listening without judgment, curiosity, compassion, and honesty, including the willingness to sit with someone in a hard moment without rushing them through it.
Built on clinical integrity
Good therapy is grounded in clarity, competence, and consistency. From your first contact with us, you can expect a straightforward intake process, a therapist matched to your needs, clear goals set early on, and a collaborative treatment plan. We're in-network with most major insurance providers, including Aetna, Anthem, CareSource, Cigna, and United Healthcare, and most new clients can be scheduled within about 48 hours.
You don't need to know exactly what's wrong or have the right words before reaching out. Sometimes the first step is simply saying, "I think I need some help" — that's enough to start.
Why "After the Storm"?
Storms are part of life. Some arrive suddenly; others build slowly. Sometimes the storm is something that happened to us — sometimes it's a season we never expected, or simple exhaustion from holding everything together. But storms don't last forever, and even when circumstances can't change right away, we can learn new ways to navigate them. After the Storm Counseling represents hope, resilience, and the possibility of what comes next.
Why clients choose After the Storm Counseling
People choose our Columbus-area practice because they want more than the first available appointment — they want the right fit. That means a team of licensed therapists with different specialties and approaches, care for children, teens, adults, couples, and families, and the flexibility of both in-person visits and telehealth across Ohio.
Ready to find a therapist who fits you?
Call (614) 783-6010 or reach out here to get started — most new clients are seen within about 48 hours.
Meet Our Team
Cindy Herzberg - MBA, Ed.D., LPCC-S, CCTP-II, CSTP (level III), Owner, Clinical Director
Dr. Cindy Herzberg, LPCC-S, is the founder and owner of After the Storm Counseling, bringing more than 25 years of experience helping individuals, couples, and families through anxiety, trauma, grief, and relationship challenges. She holds a doctorate in Counselor Education and Supervision, along with advanced certifications in trauma and sound therapy, which she integrates alongside evidence-based psychotherapy. Dr. Herzberg believes healing begins with genuine connection, and is honored to help clients build resilience and create lasting change. Read more
Jordan Dellinger - MSW, LISW-S, Clinical Supervisor
Jordan brings extensive experience in both client care and clinical supervision. With a strong background in supporting individuals through therapeutic services, Jordan has also demonstrated leadership as a clinical supervisor.
Recently, Jordan transitioned into a dedicated clinical supervision role at After the Storm Counseling, where they serve as a member of the administrative team. In this capacity, Jordan provides direct clinical supervision to dependently licensed social workers, ensuring high-quality care and ongoing professional development within the organization. Email: jordand@afterthestormcounseling.com
Dr. Dina Miller - PhD., LPCC-S, Therapist
Dina is a Licensed Professional Clinical Counselor with supervisor endorsement and 30+ years of experience in community mental health and university settings. She holds a doctorate in Counselor Education and Supervision from Ohio University and trained extensively in Gestalt therapy, EMDR, DBT, and Brief Solution Focused Therapy. Dina works with adults and some youth navigating mood variability, trauma, grief, anger, identity, and interpersonal struggles. She believes therapy thrives on respectful, open dialogue, and helps clients feel safe to be both challenged and supported as they grow. Email: dinam@afterthestormcounseling.com
Heather Moore - MSE, LPCC, Therapist
Heather Moore earned her Master's in Clinical Mental Health Counseling from the University of Dayton. She has worked primarily in community-based settings with children, adolescents, and families, providing individual and family counseling and crisis intervention, as well as in private practice with adults. Heather treats anxiety, depression, trauma, grief, family conflict, and self-esteem concerns using a person-centered, trauma-informed approach with CBT, mindfulness, and DBT techniques. She is dedicated to helping clients build on their own strengths within a safe, trusting therapeutic relationship. Email: heatherm@afterthestormcounseling.com
Laura Starcher - MA, LPCC, Therapist
Laura is a Licensed Professional Clinical Counselor earned her Bachelors in Psychology and Masters in Clinical Mental Health Counseling from Capital University. Her background includes outpatient and crisis work, as well as five years as an Independent Provider for people with disabilities. An LGBTQ+ and neurodivergent affirming counselor, Laura specializes in depression, anxiety, and trauma, taking an eclectic approach that draws on CBT, DBT, ACT, and Gestalt Therapy. She focuses on supporting each client's individual goals and creating a safe, welcoming space for them to build the life they want. Email: lauras@afterthestormcounseling.com
Jennifer Mitchell - MSW, LSW, Therapist
Jennifer earned her Master's in Social Work in 2023 and a Master's in Early Childhood Studies in 2016, both from Walden University. Her background includes work with children and families in Head Start settings, as a foster parent, and providing therapy to children in foster care. Jennifer specializes in trauma, ADHD, anxiety, and behavior challenges in children and adolescents, using CBT, trauma-focused CBT, solution-focused therapy, and play therapy. She takes a culturally sensitive, client-centered approach, building trust with each client to help them feel at ease and live their best life. Email: jenniferm@afterthestormcounseling.com
Molly Krile - MS, LPCC, Therapist
When stress, anxiety, or trauma make life feel like it's unraveling, it makes sense to seek support — someone to help you see yourself more clearly, strengthen relationships, and feel more at ease day to day. Molly's honored to walk that path with you. She believes you are your own best resource, and sees therapy as a partnership built on trust, freedom, and authenticity — a judgment-free space to process what's affecting your life safely, at your own pace. Reaching out takes bravery. Molly hopes you'll take a breath and call or email to see how she can help. Email: mollyk@afterthestormcounseling.com
Georgie Bracy - MS, LPCC, Therapist
Georgie is a dedicated counselor grounded in integrity, communication, respect, honesty, and compassion. She earned her undergraduate degree in Psychology from Marshall University, sparking a lifelong interest in understanding people and their experiences. She went on to complete a master's in Adult Learning, Training, and Development, strengthening her ability to support others' growth. After more than 10 years in corporate banking and healthcare, Georgie returned to school during the pandemic to pursue her calling in counseling, earning her master's in Counseling Education from Capital University in May 2022. Email: georgieb@afterthestormcounseling.com
Themba Msisha - MA, LPC Therapist - Supervised by Dr. Cindy Herzberg, LPCC-S
Themba graduated with a Master of Arts in Clinical Mental Health Counseling from Washington Adventist University in Maryland. Themba strongly believes in the need for everyone to be kind to themselves. He believes it is extremely important to be person-centered in his approach, which means he will only use a model if it fits your needs.
He also understands how difficult anxiety can be to deal with, as it is something he has personal experience with. Email: thembam@afterthestormcounseling.com
Aaron Carey - MS, LPC, Therapist
Aaron has his Master's in Clinical and Mental Health Counseling from Eastern Michigan University and over eight years of experience supporting clients across the lifespan. He provides individual therapy to children, adolescents, and adults using CBT, Solution-Focused, and Person-Centered Therapy, with a clinical focus on anxiety, depression, trauma, and crisis intervention. Aaron is passionate about empowering clients through resilience-building, psychoeducation, and practical coping strategies, and his work across hospital, community, and higher education settings reflects his commitment to reducing stigma and promoting mental wellness. Email: aaronc@afterthestormcounseling.com
Samantha Armogast - M.Ed., LPCC, Therapist
Sam has her Master of Education in Clinical Mental Health Counseling. Based in our Grandview Heights office, with telehealth available across Ohio, she works with young adults and adults facing anxiety, depression, trauma, substance use, relationship difficulties, and major life transitions. Sam draws on evidence-based approaches including Brainspotting, Motivational Interviewing, CBT, and Internal Family Systems, tailoring treatment to each client's needs. She takes a collaborative, compassionate approach, meeting clients where they are to build resilience, insight, and lasting emotional well-being. Email: samanthaa@afterthestormcounseling.com
Amber Protopopow - MSW, LSW, Therapist - Supervised by Jordan Dellinger, LISW-S
Amber received her MSW from The Ohio State University. Her background spans psychiatric hospitals, substance use treatment, and correctional settings, shaping her understanding of crisis support and long-term healing. She works with adolescents and adults facing anxiety, depression, trauma, emotional dysregulation, identity and self-esteem concerns, and relationship difficulties, with a special interest in neurodivergent-affirming care. Amber integrates TF-CBT, CBT, and strengths-based, trauma-informed approaches in a collaborative, direct, and compassionate style, helping clients build practical coping skills and lasting change. Email: amberp@afterthestormcounseling.com
Alexis Blake - MS, LPC, Therapist - Supervised by Cindy Herzberg, LPCC-S
Alexis Blake is a Licensed Professional Counselor who takes a client-centered, trauma-informed approach, using EMDR and DBT to help clients process trauma and build the tools to feel empowered and equipped for life's challenges. She has worked with clients across a wide age range, from adolescents to retirees, including survivors of sexual trauma, abuse, and trafficking, and those managing anxiety, depression, bipolar disorder, PTSD, and other trauma-related concerns. Alexis believes clients belong in the driver's seat of their healing, with safety, compassion, and a strong therapeutic relationship guiding every session. Email: alexisb@afterthestormcounseling.com
Collin Pfaff - MSW, LSW, Therapist - Supervised by Jordan Dellinger, LISW-S
Collin Pfaff (he/him) is a Licensed Social Worker and a background in college counseling, substance use treatment, and community mental health. He offers a relaxed, collaborative, strengths-based space where clients can show up as they are, helping them process shame, guilt, and grief and move toward meaningful change. Trained in CBT, ACT, Solution-Focused Therapy, Motivational Interviewing, and Schema Therapy, Collin also draws on his background as a former yoga teacher to bring mind-body awareness into sessions with teens, young adults, adults, and couples facing addiction, trauma, anxiety, depression, and relationship challenges. Email: collinp@afterthestormcounseling.com
Sandra Stewart - MSW, LISW, Therapist
Sandra is a compassionate, client-centered therapist specializing in GLP-1–related mental health, BPD, depression, anxiety, domestic violence, and trauma. She creates a warm space where clients can explore their experiences at their own pace, using CBT and Solution-Focused approaches informed by how biology, environment, and personal history shape mental health, with faith-based approaches available upon request. Sandra also supports people navigating child welfare issues, including biological parents, adoptive parents, and youth with special needs, helping clients build resilience, emotional stability, and lasting well-being. Email: sandras@afterthestormcounseling.com
Marla Rhodes - MS, LPC, Therapist - Supervised by Cindy Herzberg, LPCC-S
Marla specializes in working with children, adolescents, and adults facing mental health and behavioral challenges, using an evidence-based, client-centered approach to help clients build insight, healthier coping strategies, and lasting change. She earned a Master's in Counseling from the University of Dayton, and completed doctoral coursework in Rehabilitation Counseling, also at Ohio State. Her background includes work in addiction centers and vocational agencies supporting individuals with severe mental health diagnoses, as well as time spent teaching as an adjunct professor to counseling graduate students. Email: marlar@afterthestormcounseling.com
Heather Englund - MSW, LSW, Therapist
Heather is a Clinical Therapist specializing in co-occurring disorders, with additional experience as a Clinical Therapist at an addiction treatment center. She holds a Master of Social Work from Chamberlain University and completed clinical internships in psychiatry at the University of Florida's Shands Medical Center and in the Crisis Unit at Aspire Health Partners in Orlando. Heather spent 20+ years in advertising and marketing before pursuing her passion for addiction medicine and mental health treatment. An Ohio State graduate and Buckeye fan, she's also a mom of two college-aged kids and a Columbus foodie. Email: heathere@afterthestormcounseling.com
Shannon Gaines - Administrative Assistant
Shannon is the Administrative Assistant at After the Storm Counseling. She holds a degree in Criminal Justice, but her passion lies in mental health, with experience working alongside mental and behavioral health, reentry, and homeless populations. Shannon knows reaching out can feel challenging, and she's here to make that first call easier — helping you connect with the right therapist and feel supported from the very first conversation. Whenever you're ready to begin, Shannon is just a phone call away. Email: shannong@afterthestormcounseling.com
